TICKER - The Record Shows, They Took The Blows

Not all write-downs are created equal.

Not all write-downs are created equal. That’s a lesson being personally and painfully learned during this season of reckoning on Wall Street, as big banks are taking king-size hits against earnings because of losses on mortgage-backed securities, structured debt products and loans backing leveraged buyouts. Already the damage has helped claim the jobs of two CEOs -- Merrill Lynch & Co.'s Stan O’Neal and Citigroup’s Charles Prince. Looking at the size of these write-downs as a percentage of the firms’ market capitalization, however, provides some interesting context. Financial titans like Bank of America and JPMorgan Chase & Co. are big enough that their third-quarter losses were less than 1 percent of their market values. But for smaller, less diversified firms that took risks on par with their bigger rivals, the outcome looks far worse. Merrill’s $8.37 billion write-down, for instance, represented more than 11 percent of its market cap.

Market 3Q Market
Cap Write- % Of Cap
At End 2Q Down Market 11/1 Close
Company ($ billion) ($ million) Cap ($ billion)
Merrill Lynch & Co. $74.90 $8,370 11.17% $53.20
Credit Suisse 74.5 3,600 4.83 67.5
Bear Stearns Cos. 21.7 700 3.23 15.6
Deutsche Bank 97.1 3,100 3.19 63.3
UBS 129.4 3,700 2.86 98.5
Lehman Brothers Holdings 41.6 700 1.68 32.1
Goldman Sachs Group 107 1,480 1.39 95.5
Morgan Stanley 73.3 940 1.28 66.2
Citigroup 252.2 2,700 1.07 191.6
JPMorgan Chase & Co. 164.7 1,640 0.9 148.9
Bank of America 222.1 1,573 0.71 202.8
Sources: Company filings, Yahoo! Finance.

Related