The VALUEx investment conference I hosted last month in Vail, Colorado started with a presentation by Josh Tarasoff, a general partner at Greenlea Lane Capital, whose long-stock idea was Amazon at the time trading at a modest 179 times trailing earnings. The rich valuation was not lost on Josh. In fact, this was a perfect presentation to start the conference, as the theme of the conference was to challenge our thinking, that is to borrow a line from Apple to think different. Amazon is one of the best-managed and most innovative companies in the U.S., if not globally. It constantly pushes the boundaries of what it is. It went into cloud hosting because it felt it had unique expertise running its own enormous website, and now Amazon is going into supply it will ship goods to you if you run a retail operation.
Joshs take on Amazon was that it changes the way we shop. Our normal brick and mortar shopping habits are simple: We go to stores every so often, where the merchants have performed their black art of merchandise selection, trying to maximize their limited real estate to have the highest appeal to the average shopper (to be more precise: the shopper with the largest wallet). Amazon doesnt try to appeal to the average shopper or to the wealthiest one, it appeals to the most important shopper you. Its merchandising strategy is simple: Supply everything! With the Internet and thus Amazon being on our smart phones, tablets, PCs, etc., we can shop on Amazon whenever we realize we need something instantly.
Amazon is habit-forming for younger generations and habit-changing for older ones. This way to shop will gradually become embedded into the DNA of younger generations. A few days ago I needed an iPhone car charger. I didnt add it to my mental shopping list of things to buy next time I go to Best Buy, I simply fired up the Amazon app on my iPhone and bought it. I almost cannot think of a second website where Id go if I needed to buy something. I might Google it if it was an expensive item; if not Id just go directly to Amazon.
Amazons brick-and-mortar-free cost structure puts it at a competitive advantage against other retailers. The thing I find very refreshing about Amazon is that it allows its competitors to post their merchandise on the Amazon website they can even do so at lower prices if they like. If a customer buys the competitors product, Amazon still makes a commission on the sale. Though weve been conditioned by Amazon to think of this as a normal way of doing business online, think about how this would look in the brick-and-mortar setting. Imagine Kohls allowing Target to put its pair of Nike shoes right next to Kohls pair of the same shoes, at a lower price.
Joshs argument was that online shopping has just a 3 percent market share of total retail sales, but that sometime down the road, it will have 20 percent. Amazon, he believes, will grow at a faster rate than the overall online shopping market. He pointed out that Amazons growth rate actually accelerated over the last few years. Smart phones and tablets were probably the accelerators, as they provide instant online access to the worlds largest store and are great price-comparison tools (especially if you are visiting a Best Buy store). Joshs Amazons investment story is not only dependent on future sales but on its margins expanding theyve declined from 4.6 percent in 2010 to 1.8 percent in 2011. Josh believes that growth and investments in new projects are depressing margins.
You may agree or disagree with Joshs case for Amazon, but it demonstrates his ability to think outside the value box. Josh considers himself a value investor and believes there is value in Amazon; you just need to have a very long time horizon. There is value in growth, however, when the bulk of a companys value lies in the significant growth of future cash flows. But your confidence level in the sustainability of high growth has to be incredibly high, as a small change in growth assumptions will tank the stock.
The Amazon story is interesting to me for a different reason. Not unlike the Apple iPhone that went through and rearranged all the players in the cell phone industry, Amazon is like a huge plow that is ripping through the retailer industry and transforming it and other industries (it has already changed the book business). I wrote recently about Best Buy, but Best Buy is the low-hanging fruit, the obvious casualty. I keep thinking, which industry will be next?