By Marlene Hassine Konqui and Jean Baptiste Berthon
Despite suggestions that active managers would enjoy the new higher volatility regime this year, the signs are that alpha generation has already deteriorated. So, what’s next?
Since the February correction, stocks in all regions have started moving in sync as investors focused on trade and geopolitical concerns, a potential peak in the economic cycle and worries about the pace of reforms in Europe and Japan. As a result, company fundamentals and the information advantage became less central to returns.
As well as increasingly moving in the same direction at the same time, stock dispersion – a measure of the difference between individual stock and index returns – is also narrowing, again hampering active managers. The exceptions are the emerging markets, where elevated commodity prices, a healthier economic pulse and relatively easy financial conditions should still support alpha generators.
How to Blend Active and Passive Funds Over the Next Few Months
When it comes to choosing the right investment vehicle for a given market, we believe the optimal portfolio would currently look like this:
The World of Alpha Today
Based on our research, here’s where we believe to be the alpha hits and misses in the coming months.
Europe: Q1 Outperformers = 58%
Europe is at an earlier stage in the cycle, so a wide range of stocks still offer upside potential given greater capex, operational leverage and other catalysts – especially if politics don’t prove as problematic as feared. Theoretically then, alpha conditions are favourable. For now, however, the political backdrop is deterring investors (as it impedes reform) as are euro appreciation and peaking economic growth. The latest earnings season was decent, but unimpressive.
Europe verdict: MISS! We’re not sure alpha potential will be realised as we move into the summer months
US: Q1 Outperformers = 19%
As it did in the rest of the world, February’s correction spurred a recorrelation across US stocks and sectors. We believe it could last. Meanwhile, a transitory rise in dispersion will not create meaningfully higher alpha generation potential. However, there could be some opportunity among stocks sensitive to strong themes including tax reform, wage growth, or the energy revival. Earnings results have been robust, yet investors appear to be focusing more on warning signs of a possible peak in earnings – to the extent that positive surprises have been shrugged off and disappointments dealt with more severely. Returns following earnings announcements were primarily driven by sector and broader market moves rather than company idiosyncrasies.
US verdict: MISS! Alpha conditions are no better than they were in Q1.
Japan: Q1 Outperformers = 31%
Conditions for alpha generators in Japan are similar to those in Europe. The potential appears significant with a number of themes at play including tax reform, the implementation of Abe’s “third arrow” (reforming corporate governance structures) and greater spending on defence. Yet, political risks are catching up with the leadership, which could make the implementation of reforms and constitutional changes more challenging. Broader market sentiment and yen gyrations will continue to dominate in our view.
Japan verdict: MISS! Potential also disguises reality in Japan. We expect little improvement as we move into summer.
Emerging Markets: Q1 Outperformers = 33%
It’s true monetary normalisation and peaking economic growth in the developed world is weakening some of the external support for EM markets, but various local factors are beginning to prompt greater divergence between stocks and augment existing alpha potential. Equity correlations are also substantially lower. Right now, slowing in China, trade concerns, and tech are central to the prospects for Asian countries and their companies. Meanwhile, elections in Venezuela, Brazil and Mexico, and progress in NAFTA talks should drive Latin American markets. The situation in the Middle East, any renewal of the standoff between the US and Russia, and the pace of European growth will dominate in EMEA.
EM Verdict: HIT! The alpha environment is improving in emerging markets.
Marlene Hassine Konqui is Head of ETF Research at Lyxor, and Jean Baptiste Berthon is a Senior Cross Asset Strategist at Lyxor.
THIS DOCUMENT IS DIRECTED AT PROFESSIONAL INVESTORS ONLY
This document is for the exclusive use of investors acting on their own account and categorised either as “Eligible Counterparties” or “Professional Clients” within the meaning of Markets In Financial Instruments Directive 2004/39/EC.