This content is from: Corner Office

Carnegie Corp.’s Next Chief Investment Officer Is Mark Baumgartner

After a rash of poaching this fall, the foundation has a successor to its much-admired former chief Kim Lew.

Carnegie Corp. of New York has hired Mark Baumgartner — chief investment officer at the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, N.J. — to lead the foundation’s expansive portfolio and rebuild a hollowed-out investment team, digital IAS records show.

Baumgartner takes over from former CIO Kim Lew, who kicked off a wave of departures this fall when she ascended to lead Columbia University’s famed investment office. 

Over roughly six weeks, Carnegie Corp. lost four of its highest-ranking fund professionals to peer institutions and the private sector. Arguably, the fund became a victim of its own talent-development success.

Managing director Alisa Mall — often cited as Lew’s heir apparent — moved to a top job at Foresite Capital, a specialist in life sciences and health investing. Fellow managing directors Ken Lee and Brooke Jones became first-time CIOs at Children’s Health in Dallas, and Bryn Mawr College, respectively. 

[II Deep Dive: Heir Apparent at Carnegie Corp. Exits for Biotech Venture Firm]

Baumgartner has secured the task of rebuilding the top-performing investment operation while running its multi-billion dollar portfolio — substantially larger than the $800 million he oversaw at IAS. 

He arrives with a deep background in managing money for Tristate-area institutions. Prior to IAS, Baumgartner led asset allocation and risk at the Ford Foundation, and held top jobs at Morgan Stanley Investment Management’s outsourced CIO group.

Baumgartner is also a rocket scientist. The Princeton University alum earned a doctorate in aerospace engineering before pivoting to the earthly pursuits of Wall Street. 

With the CIO role freshly vacant, IAS is down to a tiny investment team led by director Jeff Gatto, Baumgartner’s trusted second-in-command for many years. He’s supported by analyst Adam Solan, who joined last year after a taxing search involving nearly 500 applicants and no professional recruiter.

Carnegie Corp. likewise opted to DIY its hunt for a new investment chief, whereas elite institutions typically retain one of a handful of specialty headhunters to assist. But the foundation picked and secured Baumgartner in just a few months, completing the highly competitive search in roughly half the time it normally takes. 

Spokespeople for Carnegie and IAS did not respond with comments by time of publication. 

Related Content