150x178lawrence-marsh-4.jpg

Lawrence Marsh

Lawrence Marsh Barclays

SECOND TEAM

Lisa Gill JPMorgan

THIRD TEAM

Robert Willoughby BofA

RUNNERS-UP

Thomas Gallucci Merrill Lynch ; Ricky Goldwasser UBS

Lawrence Marsh, who ­moved to Barclays Capital after its parent ac­quired Lehman Brothers last month, remains in the top spot for a fifth consecutive year (and for the eighth time in the past nine years). Money managers say the 48-year-old researcher is “a stalwart on the sector” who delivers “top-notch work” on earnings models. Marsh proved his expertise in February by reiterating his long-term overweight on supplemental health benefits vendor Health­Extras, at $26.55, after the Rockville, ­Maryland–based com­pany’s fourth-­quarter results met Marsh’s already bullish forecasts and promised further growth ahead. As of mid-­September the stock had zipped up 19.7 percent, to $31.77, far ahead of the sector’s 11.8 percent plunge over the same period. Lisa Gill of ­JPMorgan Securities, who advances one position to second place, publishes the “go-to primer on the sector,” while also hitting “home run” calls, investors say. One example: Gill’s long-­standing buy recommendation, dating back to November 2006, on Express Scripts, a pharmacy benefits man­ager headquartered in St. Louis, on rising profits. In the 12 months ended mid-­September, the share price surged 39.8 percent. Down one notch to third place, Banc of America Securities’ Robert Willoughby “knows which pharmacies are getting the business and, more important, which are able to fill orders at the lowest internal cost,” explains one port­folio man­ager. Willoughby initiated coverage of Louisville, ­Kentucky–based phar­macy ser­vices vendor Phar­Merica Corp. in August 2007 with a buy recommendation, at $16.11, owing to its growing market share. Through mid-­September 2008, Phar­Merica’s stock was up a ­very ­healthy 54.3 percent, to $24.86.

Return to The Best Analysts of the Year

Return to Rankings